DWQA Questions › Category: KINARM End-Point Lab › Difference between End-Point and Exoskeleton robot
Why are the force capabilities and controllability different for the End-Point and Exoskeleton robots?
1 Answers
The reasons for the different force capabilities between the two robots areย two-fold. The first difference is due to the internal mechanics of the twoย robots such that the End-Point can produce 50% more torque. The secondย difference is due to the length of the linkage segments and equation relating forces and torques ( F = T / r ). With the KINARMย End-Point robot, the linkage lengths are fixed, so the forces at the handle areย the same for any subject. However, with the KINARM Exoskeleton, theย linkage lengths are adjusted for subject size. As a subject getsย taller (i.e. with longer arm lengths), then the force that the Exoskeleton canย produce at the hand (or fingertip) gets smaller because the magnitude ofย possible torque stays constant.
The reason for the differences in controllability are completelyย independent from the issues of force production, and are entirely due to theย differences in compliance between the End-Point and Exoskeleton robots. Theย KINARM End-Point robot is a much stiffer robot, which enables much higher gainsย to be implemented before the system becomes unstable. Because the limitation of the Exoskeleton is inย the compliance of the mechanical design itself and not the controller, the only way around thisย problem is to either have a completely different robotic design (e.g. the End-Pointย robot) or to add other custom feedback devices and use those. Weย have not done this latter suggestion ourselves, but at least one of our customers has added anย accelerometer to the Exoskeleton linkage to improve the kinematic feedback toย the controller (they were attempting inertial compensation and were able to get ~50% compensation). The
theory behind this approach is that by placing an accelerometer out on theย linkage, that feedback then bypasses most of the robotic compliance, thereby allowingย higher gains in the feedback control. This approach is not trivial,ย unless you have extensive engineering experience, and although it would improveย the controllability, we cannot provide any guidance on what sort of gains youย might derive from it for different feedback/control types.
Please login or Register to submit your answer